EnglishShortStories.com

What the Butter Thief Really Wanted

Story

Bhoomi had redone the same fraction problem four times, and four times the answer came out wrong. Her exam was two days away, and the notebook page had more crossed-out lines than solved ones.

She set the pencil down at the edge of the desk, careful, the way she set down everything.

Dadi arrived with two steel tumblers of turmeric milk, though only one chair was pulled out. She set the spare tumbler on the desk anyway, the way she always did in case someone dropped by.

"You'll wear a hole in that page before you solve the sum," Dadi said. "Come. Let me tell you about the biggest thief in Vrindavan."

"Dadi, I have to study."

"Five minutes. Then back to your sums."

Bhoomi turned her chair around, the way she always did — reluctant on the outside, already listening underneath.

"Little Krishna," Dadi began, "used to sneak into every house in the village. Not for jewels, not for coins. For butter. Fresh, cool, kept high on a shelf so no child could reach it."

"I know this story, Dadi."

"You know the ending. You don't know why he did it."

"The gopis hid the butter pots higher each week — behind grain sacks, tied to the rafters, inside locked cupboards. And each week Krishna found a new way in. He stacked pots into towers, climbed on Balarama's shoulders, slipped through windows no wider than a cat. By the time his fingers reached the butter, half of it was already smeared on his cheeks, his knees, the floor, his friends."

"So he got the butter. That's the point, no?"

Dadi shook her head. "Watch what happens after. The gopis would run out shouting, waving their ladles, and Krishna would run — laughing, butter dripping off his chin, not one drop of guilt on his face. Some days he barely tasted it before it fell out of his hands. And still he came back the next morning."

"Why would he come back if he didn't even get to eat it?"

"Because the eating was never the reward, kanna. The climbing was. The plan. The second before a gopi turned around and caught him red-handed and couldn't stop laughing either. That whole morning — the thinking, the trying, the getting caught, the running — that was what he came back for. The butter just happened to be sitting at the top of it."

Bhoomi looked down at her own hands, then at Dadi's, and noticed for the first time that the turmeric stain on Dadi's fingers had probably been there, in one shade or another, for forty years of cooking the same dishes and still trying to get them right.

"If Krishna had thought only about the butter," Dadi said, "one failed climb and he'd have stopped forever. Nobody remembers how many pots he actually reached, three thousand years later. They remember how he tried."

She reached over and turned Bhoomi's notebook the right way round, the way Bhoomi always held it sideways when she was stuck.

Bhoomi looked at the second, untouched tumbler still sitting on the edge of the desk, the milk skin already forming on top, and didn't ask who Dadi had really poured it for.

She picked her pencil back up and looked at the fraction again — not at the blank space where the answer should sit, but at the first line, where she'd have to decide what to try next.

For the first time all evening, she wasn't thinking about ninety percent.

She was thinking about the climb.

Worksheet

💡 Reading Tip: Read the story aloud together, then ask what the second tumbler on the desk might mean — who do you think Dadi usually pours it for?

1. Vocabulary (5) — smeared, groan, climb, guilt, reward
2. Match the Words (5) — same 5 words to their meanings
3. MCQ (5)

  1. What was Bhoomi struggling with? a) Spelling b) A fraction problem c) A poem d) A drawing
  2. What does Dadi bring along with the story? a) Coffee b) Two tumblers of turmeric milk c) A book d) Sweets
  3. What did Krishna sneak into houses for? a) Jewels b) Coins c) Butter d) Sweets
  4. What does Bhoomi notice about Dadi's hands? a) They are cold b) The turmeric stain, there for forty years of trying c) They are shaking d) They smell of butter
  5. What does Dadi say Krishna really came back for? a) The butter b) To be scolded c) The climbing and the plan d) The gopis' laughter alone

4. True/False (5)

  1. Bhoomi's exam is one week away. (False — two days)
  2. Dadi brings out two tumblers even though only Bhoomi is there. (True)
  3. Krishna always managed to taste all the butter he reached. (False)
  4. Dadi says the story is remembered for how many pots Krishna reached. (False)
  5. By the end, Bhoomi thinks only about her score. (False)

5. Fill in the Blanks (5)Word bank: smeared, groan, climb, guilt, reward

  1. Bhoomi let out a ______ when her fourth answer came out wrong.
  2. Krishna's face was often ______ with butter after his morning raids.
  3. Dadi says the ______ was never the point — the trying was.
  4. Krishna ran off laughing, without a trace of ______ on his face.
  5. Bhoomi picked up her pencil to begin the ______ toward understanding, not the mark.

6. Short Answer (5)

  1. Why is Bhoomi afraid before her exam?
  2. Why did the gopis keep hiding the butter pots higher?
  3. What does Bhoomi notice about Dadi's hands, and why does it matter?
  4. According to Dadi, what would have happened if Krishna only cared about the butter?
  5. What do you think the second, untouched tumbler on the desk means?

7. Creative Thinking (2)

  1. Imagine you are one of the gopis. Write three sentences about how you feel each time Krishna outsmarts you.
  2. Who do you think Dadi usually pours the second tumbler for? Write a few sentences imagining who it might be.

8. Character Reflection
Think about a time you kept trying at something difficult. Was there a part of the trying itself that you enjoyed, separate from finishing or winning? Write about it in a few sentences.

9. Creative Writing
Write a short scene (6–8 sentences) where Bhoomi comes home after her exam and tells Dadi about it. Does she talk about her marks first, or about something she understood while solving a problem?


Need Answers Later?

Complete the worksheet first and then check your answers.

Answer Key QR Code

Scan with your phone to view the answer key online.

— or —

Finish the worksheet first — the answer key unlocks after a short delay.